| 1,535 | 9 | 135 |
| 下载次数 | 被引频次 | 阅读次数 |
既有研究关注“医美热”背后的结构性因素，但难以回答“医美热”何以持续的理论问题。为此，文章采用希林“肉身实在论”的理论框架，关注身体生成性特征与社会约束性特征之间的联系，并基于某中高档医疗美容机构的田野调查对这一问题进行探究。文章认为，借由身体实现的医美与社会结构的互构使得“医美热”不断持续。在这一过程中，散见于不同生活领域中同美貌相关的歧视性社会规则，如亲密关系领域中“郎才女貌”的婚姻标准，劳动力市场领域里的“美容溢价”，以及日常生活领域中外貌同个人发展机会的关联，使得美貌不断累积优势，并抬高个体寻求医美的意愿。而新自由主义文化下的医美实践，则借“赋权”与“自由”之名，以个体主体性的身体改造为代价，更以其他未经身体修饰的大多数人的身体贬值为代价，利用、加深并巩固了前述隐蔽的社会歧视性规则，以最大化身体修饰的效益。这或许是理解当前“医美热”争议的核心。
Abstract：Established studies have paid attention to the structural factors behind the “medical aesthetics craze”, but it is difficult to explain the theoretical issue of why the “cosmetic surgery craze” can be sustained.Therefore, this paper adopts the theoretical framework of Shilling's Corporeal Realism, focuses on the connection between the bodily generative and socially constrained traits, and explores this issue based on a field study of mid to high-grade medical aesthetics companies. The paper argues that it is the inter-construction of medical aesthetics with the social structure through the body that makes the medical aesthetics craze continue.In this process, the discriminatory social rules related to beauty are scattered throughout the life course, such as the marital criterion of “good looks” in the realm of intimacy, the “beauty premium” in the realm of the labor market, and the association of appearance with opportunities for personal development in the realm of daily life, and allow for the accumulation of advantages of good looks, which motivates individuals to seek medical beauty. The so-called “empowerment” and “freedom” of medical aesthetics take advantage of these rules, deepening and reinforcing the current hidden social discriminatory rules to maximize the benefits of body modification at the cost of individual body modification, and at the cost of devaluing the bodies of the majority of the non-modified population. This is perhaps the core of understanding the current controversy over the “medical aesthetics craze”.
勃朗特，劳伦，2016，《残酷的乐观》，载汪民安、郭晓彦主编《生产（第11辑）：德勒兹与情动》，赵文译，南京：江苏人民出版社。
德勤，2022，《踵事增华，应时顺势：中国医美行业2022年度洞悉报告》，https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/cn/Documents/dtt-china-medical-aesthetic-industry-outlook-2022-zh-220816-whitepaper.pdf。
邓卫广、高庭苇，2019，《外貌与社会资本形成：美貌溢价的再检验》，《劳动经济研究》第6期。
费舒澜，2016，《美貌者进入了高收入职业吗？》，《劳动经济研究》第6期。
顾天竹，2018，《美貌溢价：劳动力市场歧视是主因吗？--基于中国劳动力动态调查数据的实证研究》，《财经研究》第2期。
顾天竹、纪月清，2017，《论社会资本中的美貌溢价--基于劳动力社会网络外貌差异的实证》，《经济与管理研究》第9期。
郭继强、费舒澜、林平，2017，《越漂亮，收入越高吗？--兼论相貌与收入的“高跟鞋曲线”》，《经济学（季刊）》第1期。
黄燕华，2020，《消费文化中的“美丽迷思”--青年女性整形个案研究》，《青年研究》第4期。
李升、李敏，2022，《当代青年女性“容貌焦虑”的社会机制分析》，《中国青年研究》第4期。
刘传红、吴思琪，2022，《颜值幻象与美丽透支：医疗美容广告批判及其治理》，《中南民族大学学报》（人文社会科学版）第5期。
米尔斯，阿什利，2018，《美丽的标价：模特行业的规则》，张皓译，上海：华东师范大学出版社。
田甜，2023，《社交媒体与女大学生的“理想美”建构研究》，《中国青年研究》第6期。
文华，2019，《看上去很美》，刘月译，上海：华东师范大学出版社。
吴小英，2009，《市场化背景下性别话语的转型》，《中国社会科学》第2期。
希林，克里斯，2011，《文化、技术与社会中的身体》，李康译，北京：北京大学出版社。
徐婧、孟繁荣，2022，《驯服“赛博格”：美形技术凝视下的女性身体及其性别秩序》，《新闻与写作》第11期。
许琪、潘修明，2021，《美貌与地位：中国人婚姻中的匹配与交换》，《社会》第6期。
曾一果、王可心，2021，《自我的再认：〈乘风破浪的姐姐〉中年女性形象的重构》，《湖南师范大学社会科学学报》第4期。
张方旭、文军，2017，《整容过程中的身体建构--一项身体社会学的研究》，《安徽师范大学学报》（人文社会科学版）第4期。
赵杜灵，2021，《时尚消费与具身化策略：小镇中产青年女性的身份建构研究》，《中国青年研究》第5期。
钟方琦，2021,《Pick Me Up！指梦为马：后女性主义时代中国养成系女团真人秀之女性性别气质、赋权进程及新自由主义再现》，《新闻学研究》第146期。
朱舒婕、林心婕，2023，《“自然脸”还是“网红脸”：整容女性的象征性边界实践》，《当代青年研究》第1期。
Aapola,S.,Marnina,G.,&Anita,H.2004,Young Femininity:Girlhood,Power and Social Change.London:Red Globe Press.
Ahmed,S.2010,The Promise of Happiness.Durham,North Carolina:Duke University Press.
Banet-Weiser,S.2017,“‘I’m beautiful the way I am’:Empowerment,beauty,and aesthetic labour.”In Ana Sofia Elias,Rosalind Gill&Christina Scharff(eds.),Aesthetic Labour:Rethinking Beauty Politics in Neoliberalism.London:Palgrave Macmillan UK.
Bourdieu,P.2002,Distinction:A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste.Cambridge:Harvard University Press.
Br?ckling,U.2016,The Entrepreneurial Self:Fabricating a New Type of Subject.London:SAGE Publications Ltd.
Coleman,R.,&Mónica,M.F.2010,Past and future perfect?Beauty,affect and hope.Journal for Cultural Research 14(4).
Davis,K.1991,Remaking the She-Devil:A critical look at feminist approaches to beauty.Hypatia 6(2).
--.2015,Should a feminist dance tango?Some re?ections on the experience and politics of passion1.Feminist Theory 16(1).
Dosekun,S.2017,“The risky business of postfeminist beauty.”In Ana Sofia Elias,Rosalind Gill&Christina Scharff(eds.),Aesthetic Labour:Rethinking Beauty Politics in Neoliberalism.London:Palgrave Macmillan UK.
Elias,A.S.,Gill,R.,&Scharff,C.2017,“Aesthetic labour:Beauty politics in neoliberalism.”In Elias,A.S.,Gill,R.,&Scharff,C.(Eds.),Aesthetic Labour:Rethinking Beauty Politics in Neoliberalism.London:Palgrave Macmillan UK.
Feher,M.2009,Self-appreciation;or,the aspirations of human capital.Public Culture 21(1).
Gill,R.2008,Culture and subjectivity in neoliberal and postfeminist times.Subjectivity 25(1).
Harris,A.2004,Future Girl:Young Women in the Twenty-First Century.New York:Routledge.
Ji,Y.,Wu,X.,&Sun,S.et al.2017,Unequal care,unequal work:Toward a more comprehensive understanding of gender inequality in post-reform urban China.Sex Roles 77(11).
Keyser-Verreault,A.2023,“Your fatty bum is really ugly!”Gender,fat-shaming,and beauty-related tensions in contemporary taiwanese families.Journal of Family Studies 29(5).
Keyser-Verreault,A.,&Rail,G.2023,Gender,beauty and the future of neoliberalism:Aesthetic labour and women’s (anti)aspirationalism in Taiwan.Chinese Sociological Review 55(5).
Luo,W.2013,Aching for the altered body:Beauty economy and Chinese women’s consumption of cosmetic surgery.Women’s Studies International Forum 38.
Ma,H.2023,Inner and outer beauty:Exploring female beauty in contemporary China.Journal of Gender Studies 32(6).
Man,E.K.W.2000,Female bodily aesthetics,politics,and feminine ideals of beauty in China.In Peg,Z.B.&Peg,B.W.(eds.),Beauty Matters.Bloomington:Indiana University Press.
McRobbie,A.2013,Feminism,the family and the new“mediated”maternalism.New Formations 80.
--.2015,Notes on the perfect.Australian Feminist Studies 30(83).
Mears,A.2014,Aesthetic labor for the sociologies of work,gender,and beauty.Sociology Compass 8(12).
Mu,Z.&Felicia,F.T.2022,The changing patterns and determinants of stay-at-home motherhood in urban China,1982 to 2015.Journal of Comparative Family Studies 53(1).
Ringrose,J.,&Walkerdine,V.2008,Regulating the abject.Feminist Media Studies 8(3).
Rose,N.1999,Powers of Freedom:Reframing Political Thought.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
Rottenberg,C.2017,Neoliberal feminism and the future of human capital.Signs:Journal of Women in Culture and Society 42(2).
Scharff,C.2016,The psychic life of neoliberalism:Mapping the contours of entrepreneurial subjectivity.Theory,Culture&Society 33(6).
Talley,H.L.2014,Saving Face.New York:New York University Press.
Waitzkin,H.1989,A critical theory of medical discourse:Ideology,social control,and the processing of social context in medical encounters.Journal of Health and Social Behavior 30(2).
Weber,M.1978,Economy and Society:An Outline of Interpretive Sociology.Berkeley:University of California Press.
Wen,H.2021,“Gentle yet manly:Xiao xian rou,male cosmetic surgery and neoliberal consumer culture in China.”Asian Studies Review 45(2).
Widdows,H.2018,Perfect Me:Beauty as an Ethical Ideal.Princeton:Princeton University Press.
Wu,Y.,Mulkens,S.,&Alleva,J.M.2022,Body image and acceptance of cosmetic surgery in China and the Netherlands:Aqualitative study on cultural differences and similarities.Body Image 40.
Xu,G.,&Feiner,S.2007,Meinüjingji/China’s beauty economy:Buying looks,shifting value,and changing place.Feminist Economics 13(3-4).
Yang,J.2011,Nennu and shunu:Gender,body politics,and the beauty economy in China.Signs:Journal of Women in Culture and Society 36(2).
基本信息:
中图分类号:F719;C913.3
引用信息:
[1]郑叶昕,李婷,杨阳.“医美热”何以持续？——医美实践中的逻辑依赖与社会学反思[J].当代青年研究,2024,No.389(02):75-88.
2024-03-20
2024-03-20